Stella's: A Cocktail Dive
About This Spot
Stella’s: A Cocktail Dive feels like a well-kept secret nestled in the heart of Milwaukee’s James Lovell neighborhood—a place where familiarity wraps around you like a warm embrace the moment you walk through the door. It’s the kind of spot where the pace slows just enough to catch your breath, inviting you to settle in and let the evening unfold naturally.
Here, the atmosphere is refreshingly unpretentious, blending a laid-back neighborhood charm with a quietly confident passion for the craft of cocktails. Whether it’s the comforting clink of ice in a glass or the hum of easy conversation, everything feels thoughtfully rooted in genuine human connection. The bartenders don’t just serve drinks—they orchestrate the mood, knowing when to share a story, offer the perfect pour, or simply let the night speak for itself.
Drinks at Stella’s become part of the story rather than the headline—like a refreshingly tart Daiquiri or a robust Manhattan savored alongside the laughter of newfound friends. There’s a steady stream of classics, with local touches that hint at Milwaukee’s spirited character. Beer pours cold and steady, while cocktails carry just the right balance of care and creativity to keep you coming back without fuss.
In essence, this is a place where the details matter softly: the way the lighting settles, the ease between strangers turned companions, and the steady hum of good vibes. It’s not just about the perfect drink—it’s about the moments crafted in between sips, making Stella’s feel like a rare kind of home away from home.
What’s Available Here
-
Identifies as veteran-owned
-
Identifies as women-owned
-
Outdoor seating
-
Takeaway
-
Delivery
-
Bar games
-
Fast service
-
Great beer selection
-
Great cocktails
-
Sport
-
Wheelchair-accessible car park
-
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
-
Alcohol
-
Beer
-
Cocktails
-
Spirits
-
Wine
-
Seating
-
Table service
-
Toilet
-
Casual
-
Cosy
-
Groups
-
Locals
-
Tourists
-
Accepts reservations
-
Credit cards
-
Debit cards
-
NFC mobile payments
-
Credit cards
-
Free of charge street parking
Location & Hours
| Monday | 11:00 AM - 02:00 AM | |
| Tuesday | 11:00 AM - 02:00 AM | |
| Wednesday | 11:00 AM - 02:00 AM | |
|---|---|---|
| Thursday | 11:00 AM - 02:00 AM | |
| Friday | 11:00 AM - 02:30 AM | |
| Saturday | 11:00 AM - 02:30 AM | |
| Sunday | 11:00 AM - 02:00 AM |
Malcolm Bates 06 Jan 2026
Came in from Chicago with my lady, and we loved the vibe and ambiance of this place! Our bartender Tony showed us a great time and kept the drink coming, we’ll definitely be back the next time we’re in town.
Kourtney 19 Dec 2025
I came in this evening for a whiskey neat and the bottle is a tricky bottle to find (not very common). The bartender knew exactly what I was looking for and had it. He gave wonderful service and was very friendly. It’s nice to see such down on earth staff at this bar. Thank you Dimitri.
David Burroughs 07 Nov 2025
Old Style in downtown Milwaukee is the kind of bar you stumble into and immediately feel like you’ve been coming there for years. The locals were incredibly friendly—within minutes, we were sharing laughs, learning a dice game we’d never played before, and watching the basketball game like old friends. The atmosphere is unpretentious, warm, and full of good vibes. If I lived in Milwaukee, this would absolutely be my spot. Special shoutout to Tina, who was a rockstar behind the bar—quick with a drink, a smile, and genuine hospitality. She made the night even better. Don’t miss this place if you want a true local experience.
T Zigggy 06 Nov 2025
Stopped in for a relaxing Pint. Tony the day shift bartender was excellent. We had great conversation and the beers were very cold.
Jeff Martinez 30 Oct 2025
Last night before heading back home to Oklahoma, I told my husband (posting this on his behalf) that I had to stop at Sobelman’s for the best Bloody Mary before we left. Well, let me tell you—Tony makes an incredible Bloody Mary! Sorry Sobelman’s, but you’re officially off my list.
Beatrice Gadal 29 Oct 2025
This review is long overdue, but I am finally getting around to it, as promised :) I discovered Stella’s Cocktail Dive Bar on my last day in Milwaukee while in town for the Northwestern Mutual Annual meeting. I was staying at the Hilton just down the street and had no idea this gem was tucked away nearby. The second I walked in, I knew I had found my kind of spot. The atmosphere? Pure dive bar magic—low-key, welcoming, and effortlessly cool. What made the experience unforgettable, though, was the incredible crew behind the bar. Fox, Ink, and RyAnn were so welcoming and helpful when making recommendations. The vibe they create is what every bar should strive for—real, relaxed, and just the right kind of rowdy. Whether you're a local or just passing through like I was, do yourself a favor and grab a drink at Stella’s. I only wish I had found it sooner. I will 100% be visiting during next year's annual meeting! Cheers and until next time :)
Beth S 08 Oct 2025
A friend recommended Stella's so we stopped in Saturday afternoon after doing some Christmas shopping. We got a couple of open seats at the bar. The atmosphere is welcoming, we were greeted within a minute of walking in. Each of us had a couple of cocktails - Champagne Cocktail, French 75, Old Fashioned and Tom Collins - and they were perfectly prepared. Our bartenders were attentive and friendly. We 100% will be back.
Robbie Aschenbrener 19 Sep 2025
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ “Awesome local spot with unbeatable vibes!” This place is everything you want in a good dive bar — laid-back atmosphere, great music, and a crowd that feels like family by the end of the night. The drinks are strong, the prices are fair, and the vibe is just right. The real highlight, though, is the bartender Fox — super friendly, fast, and always remembers your drink. She instantly made our group welcomed and started to give the guys a hard time, all in good fun. She made sure everyone felt welcome and kept the energy fun without it ever feeling forced. Whether you’re stopping in for one or staying for a few, this bar just hits the spot every time. Highly recommend checking it out if you want good drinks, good people, and a genuinely great time.